What happened
- On October 22, Sam Robin emailed 203 addresses with no BCC: owners, renters, owners' children and outside property managers.
- Owners who moved in last month are on it. This isn't an old list someone kept. It's the Association's current roster, which is kept in management's system.
- Florida law says your email address is for Association business only, and may never go to outside third parties.
Do this now: send one email
Copy it, add your name and unit, and send it to manager@1000venetian.com. It puts on record that you never agreed to share your address, opts you out, and asks who handed it over.
Subject: I did not consent to sharing my email address — Unit [number]
To the Board of Directors and management:
[If mailing certified: This is a written inquiry under §718.112(2)(a)2, Florida Statutes.]
I never consented to receive notices by email or to the sharing of my email address. On October 22, 2026, my address was sent to 203 people, including renters and outside property managers. Under §718.111(12)(a)7, Florida Statutes, the Association must ensure email addresses are used only for Association business and are not shared with outside third parties.
- Do not share my email address, phone number or other contact information with anyone. This is my written opt-out.
- Use my address only for Association business, stated as facts. No opinions about owners or directors.
- Tell me in writing who gave my email address to the sender.
- Send me a copy of any consent I signed. If there isn't one, say so.
- Keep all records of how the list was produced.
[Name]
Unit [number]
Want an answer they have to give? Also mail it certified, with the first line filled in. The Board must then answer in writing within 30 days. If it doesn't, it can't recover its legal fees in any later dispute over your question (§718.112(2)(a)2).
Then report it
Both reports are free and online. Attach the October 22 email and the email you sent.
- Against the Association: file a condominium complaint. The state can order the Association to comply and fine it up to $5000 per offense (§718.501(1)(e)).
- Against the management company: file a complaint against a manager or firm. Managers who break the condominium law while managing a building can be fined up to $5000 per count, suspended or lose their license (§468.436).
Your address is for Association business. Nothing else.
From the statute
"An association must ensure that the e-mail addresses and facsimile numbers are only used for the business operation of the association and may not be sold or shared with outside third parties."
§718.111(12)(a)7, Florida Statutes (2025)
- Renters, family members and outside property managers are third parties. The Association has to black out your address before anything carrying it goes to them.
- Other owners get your address only if you agreed. Nobody here was asked.
- Business means facts: what was decided, what it costs, what happens next. Not opinions about owners or directors. It doesn't matter whether an owner or a director hits send.
Here is what has gone to the building instead:
From the Board President's emails to the building
"…does it stem from incompetence or is it a cheap attempt at sabotage?"
"The division you have seen in our community has a common denominator that is now in plain sight."
Julián Esses, emails to owners, 31 July 2026 and 30 September 2026
Directors have a "fiduciary relationship to the unit owners" (§718.111(1)(a)). To every owner, not just the ones who agree with them.
The owner list is for running the building. Not for fighting over it.
Protect yourself
Don't reply-all to the October 22 email: every reply sends all 203 addresses around again. And if an email from "management" asks you to pay a new way or change your bank details, call the office first.
More options, and what this won't do
Change the rule. If owners holding 20% of the voting interests petition the Board, it must put the item on a meeting agenda within 60 days (§718.112(2)(c)). Ask for a written communications rule: building-wide email limited to Association business, stated factually, with no personal characterizations of any owner, director or employee; BCC on every building-wide email; the roster released only as the law allows, and every release logged.
Court. An owner can sue the Association, or a director who "willfully and knowingly" fails to comply (§718.303(1)). The winner recovers attorney fees, so a loss can cost you the Association's fees. Expect a court order, not money. Some disputes must go to state arbitration first (§718.1255). Talk to a lawyer before you file.
The Association's defense. The law excuses an "inadvertent disclosure," but not one made with "knowing or intentional disregard of the protected nature of such information" (§718.111(12)(a)7). Once you've told them in writing that you never consented, a repeat can't be called inadvertent.
The sender. The statute puts the duty on the Association. You can ask her to delete your address. Nothing makes her.
Money. The state doesn't award damages for this, and a court is unlikely to award much.
Data-breach law. It doesn't apply. It covers an email address only when it's paired with a password or security question (§501.171).
Renters and family members. Ask the owner of your unit to send the email and name your address in it.
Sources
- Florida Statutes §718.111(1)(a) and (12)(a)7 — Directors' fiduciary duty; owners' email addresses
- Florida Statutes §718.112(2)(a)2 and (2)(c) — Written inquiries; owner petitions
- Florida Statutes §718.303(1) — Owner lawsuits
- Florida Statutes §718.501(1)(e) — What the state can order
- Florida Statutes §468.436 — Discipline of community association managers
- Florida Statutes §718.1255 — Arbitration
- Florida Statutes §501.171 — Security of personal information
- Email of October 22, 2026, signed by Sam Robin, and its recipient list, compared with the Association's owner roster
- Julián Esses, "On KWPMC's Third Amendment," email to owners, 31 July 2026; "Setting the Record Straight," email to owners, 30 September 2026
More from The Venetian Record